Skip to content

School all year round

· Martin Thorborg

School all year round was an idea I wanted to discuss in a video from January 2014. Why should all children and families take holidays at almost the same time? I wondered whether a school open throughout the year with more flexible holidays could better suit the society we lived in.

School all year round as a question about old habits

Every so often, there was discussion of teachers’ holidays and how long schools were closed. Summer holidays, autumn holidays and all the other periods. I wondered how much of that rhythm was inherited from a different society.

My explanation back then was that some of the school year’s organisation was connected with agriculture and industry. I discussed children helping with harvests and other work and factories shutting down. I also said I did not know the precise history of summer holidays.

Whatever the exact history, my question was whether the challenges the arrangement had been meant to solve were still the same. I thought we should examine whether school opening times reflected today’s society or very old needs.

Families could choose their holiday together

I provocatively suggested schools could be open 365 days a year. Of course with exceptions such as Christmas, New Year and public holidays, as in the rest of society. The idea was not that a child should attend every single day.

I imagined holidays being spread more across the year. Children and parents could decide together when to take time off instead of everyone having the same long summer holiday.

I discussed five or six weeks of holiday as a comparison with working society. It was my idea for a different arrangement, which would naturally have advantages and disadvantages.

I hoped for less pressure on the roads

One advantage I imagined concerned traffic. We spent a lot on expanding roads and other infrastructure. Meanwhile, pressure could be intense when everyone travelled through Denmark on summer holidays.

If families could spread their holidays more freely, some might choose to travel in autumn instead of taking a long summer break. My example was a family who would rather visit Florida at that time.

I thought that might spread some pressure on roads and public transport. We could then use existing infrastructure better and perhaps need less expansion.

That was a possible benefit I imagined. I had not calculated the actual size of the effect.

Holidays might become cheaper too

I also had travel prices in mind. Families with children could find holidays cost a fortune when everyone travelled during the autumn break, Easter or other shared holiday periods.

My expectation was that greater freedom to choose the timing could reduce that problem. Families could schedule holidays when it suited them, with perhaps other savings or better use of resources.

That was one reason I thought the idea worth discussing. I did not present a finished model for travel markets or schools.

I knew teaching would require a different arrangement

The obvious question was whether schools could manage pupils being absent at different times. I compared it with workplaces that had adapted from a shared industrial holiday to year-round operation.

Of course some businesses still closed together. But many others operated throughout the year. I thought they too had at some point needed to work out how holidays could function without stopping everything.

I did not think school challenges should make us abandon the idea beforehand. We needed to consider organising schools differently.

If the maths teacher was away for a fortnight, perhaps you could coordinate with other teachers or have a themed week with different content. That was an example I threw out, not a thoroughly developed teaching plan.

I said directly I could not explain exactly how to do it. My point was that an old arrangement could be challenged even if the solution was not yet finished.

Perhaps we should discuss how much holiday children needed too

When people discussed pupils starting school earlier, I also thought of another possibility: perhaps we could look at the amount of holiday instead.

I listed summer holidays, autumn and winter breaks, public holidays and other closures and guessed how many weeks they totalled. I had no precise calculation but asked whether all of it was necessary.

I hoped more teaching might make pupils more knowledgeable. I also imagined a holiday arrangement closer to the rest of the labour market could reduce arguments about teachers’ holidays.

Schools could reflect the society we lived in

At the end, I exaggerated the idea of traffic savings and joked that perhaps some road space could even be returned to agriculture. That was my way of imagining the possibilities.

My fundamental question was whether we could improve things by rethinking school opening times and holidays. Less congestion, better use of what we had and more freedom for families were among the benefits I hoped for.

That was my idea and my reflections in January 2014. I wanted schools to reflect the society the rest of us lived in and thought old habits deserved a thorough look.