Tesla vs. Audi

For me, Tesla vs. Audi is about enjoying cars and technology. I’ve bought an Audi that I’m incredibly happy with. At the same time, I’m keeping my Tesla shares. To me, there’s a big difference between who builds the nicest car to drive and who’s furthest ahead with the technology to let the car drive itself.
Thorborg’s Diary · Episode 52 · 4 April 2024
Watch the video episode
Listen in your podcast app:
All episodes on Apple Podcasts · All episodes on Spotify · All episodes on Amazon Music · RSS Feed
I’ve got a new car – and Tesla shares have taken a beating
I’m driving my new car, which I’ve had for a couple of weeks. Fuck, I’m happy with it.
There are two things I want to talk about: I’ve bought a new car, and Tesla shares have fallen. And no, my new car isn’t a Tesla.
I occasionally get comments from people saying they’ve bought Tesla shares, or that I supposedly told them to buy them. I’ve always made big caveats. You never know what’s going to happen to a stock, and nobody knows what’s going to happen with Tesla.
I still think it’s an interesting investment case. When I compare its valuation with a more mature company like Microsoft, I don’t think it looks unreasonable if Tesla achieves the growth I expect over the coming years.
But that’s my assessment. What you do with your money is entirely up to you.
I see more than a car factory
When I look at Tesla, I don’t just see the cars. I see the charging network, the work on robots, Powerwall and battery production.
I think many people underestimate the size and value of the other parts. I also see Tesla as one of the few manufacturers that can make money on electric cars at this point.
But the part that makes me particularly optimistic is the progress towards self-driving cars. I’ll come back to that, because first you need to hear about my Audi.
The old Audi has served me well
My old Audi is around ten years old. It’s run beautifully and is a really solid, lovely car: Good leather seats, a good steering wheel, a lovely gear change and quality that I’ve been incredibly happy with.
I actually still have it. It’s now done just under 200,000 kilometres, so of course things are starting to need replacing and some seals aren’t quite watertight any more. That’s what you can expect from a car of that age.
It cost around DKK 1.1 million new. I bought it for DKK 750,000 when it was about two to two and a half years old. I thought that was a sensible price for a magnificent car that’s served me really well.
My Audi e-tron GT RS is the best car I’ve owned
The one I’m driving now is an Audi e-tron GT RS. It’s unquestionably the best car I’ve ever owned, and I’ve had four different Porsches and all sorts of other things.
It’s ridiculously fast. But it’s also the build quality that makes me happy: The way the door closes, the steering wheel, the seats and their massage function. It has night vision and pretty much every option I could wish for.
The screens look great and respond quickly. Apple CarPlay just works. There’s a big B&O sound system, and everything feels properly thought through. I have very little bad to say about it.
By my calculations, a similar configuration cost around DKK 2.2 million new. I paid DKK 980,000 for mine, which is about two and a half years old.
That’s a huge loss in value for the first owner. When the dealer sells it to me at that price, the previous owner probably received less.
That’s why I don’t buy a new car in that price range. That kind of depreciation would make me feel ill.
Of course, mine will lose value too. But if, for example, I sell it in five or six years for half the price, I’ll have had a fantastic car for those years at a cost that makes sense to me.
I see it as closely related to the Porsche Taycan, but with Audi’s looks. And I think it’s much more beautiful. That’s a matter of taste, of course.
How much more can it do on its own?
Is all this just showing off about my new car? Yes, maybe ten per cent. I’m bloody happy with it. But my real point is the comparison with my old Audi.
How much has the car progressed in terms of being able to drive itself?
For me, the answer is: Almost not at all.
The adaptive cruise control works well, but it did in the old one too. I can’t think of a major difference in the driving itself when we’re talking about automation.
Okay, it can park itself. I’ve tried it a couple of times, but it nearly scared the life out of me. I find it strange and unsettling and not very intuitive.
It may well be that I haven’t learnt to use it properly. Maybe an Audi enthusiast has practised in a car park and thinks it works fine. In that case, I apologise. Maybe I’m too easily frightened or haven’t understood it.
But my experience is that there are buttons and pedals I have to deal with, and I don’t feel it’s assistance I want to use.
A very nice horse-drawn carriage
When I also see Tesla’s FSD, which they’re giving American users a chance to try free for a period here in April 2024, I think: Bloody hell, man. I’m sitting in a horse-drawn carriage. A very, very nice horse-drawn carriage.
I still think it’ll be a few years before that technology really takes off and we get it in Denmark in the way I imagine. My guess is two or three years or more.
By then, I’ll have had some fantastic years in my Audi. Then I can buy a Tesla to replace my Fiat 500e, and Audi and Tesla can fight over being car number one or two.
I definitely imagine owning a Tesla at some point. But right now, I think the Audi is much nicer to drive manually. More beautiful, more polished and more luxurious.
When it comes to automation, though, I think Tesla is far ahead.
Tesla vs. Audi: Which lead is harder to catch up with?
If Tesla wanted to make a car with the sense of quality I get in the Audi, what would they have to do?
They could choose better materials and improve the cabin experience. I know the newer Model 3 has already had an upgrade, but for me it’s still not on the same level as the Audi.
That would make the car more expensive and perhaps heavier. And weight can affect range. In my experience, my Audi doesn’t do much more than about 340 kilometres on a charge.
I imagine Tesla has prioritised lighter and cheaper materials, among other things, to get more range. And in doing so, they’ve accepted a compromise on luxury.
My assessment is that Tesla could change that priority relatively quickly if it chose to.
Now turn the question around: What would Audi have to do to reach the level of self-driving technology I see at Tesla?
It’s not just a matter of buying new machines or hiring more people at the factory. I think it’s years of work. Perhaps five to ten years, if they even choose the right direction.
I’m sceptical about whether they’ll get there on their own. I think they’re more likely to have to license software, perhaps from Tesla. Other players could emerge too, for example from China. I can’t rule that out.
I think AI requires a different way of thinking
For me, there’s a big difference between a system that works under certain conditions on a motorway and my vision of a self-driving car.
I think traditional manufacturers need to think fundamentally differently. In my view, there’s a long way from a set of programmed "if this, then that" rules to a neural network.
That’s the difference I see as central. I think Tesla’s technological lead is harder for Audi to catch up with than Audi’s level of luxury is for Tesla.
I’m keeping both the shares and the Audi
So what am I really trying to say with all this?
I’m keeping my Tesla shares. And I’m keeping my fucking Audi.
My hope is that in a few years I can buy a Tesla that’s just as nice, or an Audi with software that gives me the self-driving experience I want. And of course I hope a rise in my Tesla shares can help pay for it.
That’s an expectation, not something I know will happen.
Remember: This isn’t an invitation to buy shares or do anything at all with them. I’m usually the last person you should listen to. It’s just how I think.
Have a really lovely, excellent day.