The world economy is out of order

Economic uncertainty is on my mind at the start of 2024. The figures point in all directions. Some of the signals we see make 2023 look like a very difficult year for businesses. At the same time, fewer customers are leaving Dinero, and many choose to pay for a whole year at once. I don’t have a firm explanation, but I’ll tell you what I’m seeing.
It’s 3 January 2024. Happy New Year. I hope you had a lovely evening, whether success meant a big party or simply that the little children didn’t scream all evening.
Our three youngsters were each at their own party. Jannie and I were with some of our best friends, with fantastic food and lovely wines. We danced late into the night and got home towards five in the morning. It’s taken a little while to feel human again.
Generosity is one of the most important things in a friendship
It’s not today’s main topic, but New Year’s Eve got me thinking about what I value in friends. Generosity is very high on the list.
That doesn’t mean spending all your money on other people. If money’s tight, you can invite people over for homemade spaghetti. Perhaps without meat. And offer a beer or a glass of water.
What matters is the invitation, being present and making an effort.
I’ve found that people who are stingy with money can also be stingy with their time and friendship. You may know the type who happily lets others entertain them but always needs to go home or has forgotten their card when it’s their turn.
It’s a character trait I struggle with. I’d rather spend time with people who give of themselves and whatever they can. Luckily, those were the kind of people we spent New Year’s Eve with.
I’ve been nominated for Fonsmarkprisen
The year also started with good news for me. Berlingske reported that I’ve been nominated for Fonsmarkprisen, which recognises a contribution to the debate on liberal and conservative ideas.
That sort of thing still makes me happy. I never got a school-leaving cap, and perhaps there’s something in me that still seeks recognition. I like likes, praise and being mentioned in a newspaper. I’ll probably never get too old for that.
There are several nominees, including people such as Martin Ågerup and Dennis Nørmark. One has worked with ideas and public debate for many years, and the other has written some really good books about things including pseudo-work.
In that company, I think my own contribution is small. I write on X and sometimes let myself be persuaded to appear on Debatten with Clement Kjersgaard. I’ve written about leadership, e-commerce and entrepreneurship, but not major books about society.
This isn’t an attempt at false modesty. I’m sincerely happy about the nomination. I just think there are others who’ve made a great effort to be a distinctive and responsible public voice.
My temper comes into the debate too
For example, I’ve just had an argument with Sikandar Siddique on X. I’ve met him on a debate programme before, and I have to say we’re very far apart.
It started with a post about Israel, where I understood his wording as an extreme accusation of terrorism. I reacted pretty strongly and wrote something along the lines that I didn’t just think he was unintelligent, but unpleasant too.
I don’t want to turn this episode into a debate about the Middle East. I feel for the victims and believe there’s a lot to criticise on the different sides. But I struggle with the very categorical and extreme language the debate can end up in. And then I use extreme language back myself.
That’s part of the point: I can get carried away. I can blow a fuse and write something that others would have said more calmly.
When I think about such a prestigious award, I actually think its recipient could do with a little more self-control than I have. But I’m very happy to have been nominated.
What we look at in Dinero’s performance meeting
What I actually want to talk about is the economy. I’ve just been in a performance meeting at Dinero, and I’m simply confused by some of the things we’re seeing.
Once a month, product, marketing and management meet and go through the figures.
How many new users have created an account? How many actually become active? Someone logging in once and disappearing again isn’t enough. We want to see them set up their accounts and start using the program.
Then we look at how many free users become paying customers. We track revenue month by month, compare it with the budget and last year, and monitor the profit.
One piece of good news is that our revenue for 2023 is around three million kroner above budget. We’re really pleased with that.
The bottom line hasn’t been finalised yet. There are depreciation charges and other things the accountants need to go through. But I’d be very surprised if we didn’t also end up with a better profit than budgeted.
One of our market indicators looks very weak
We also look at the society around us. How many businesses are being founded? How many close or go bankrupt? What’s left when we subtract those disappearing from those being added?
In the figures we’re looking at, a few years ago we saw a net increase of around 17,000–18,000 businesses. I can’t remember the exact year and figure off the top of my head, but it was a completely different situation from what we’re seeing now.
For 2023, the net increase we’re looking at is around 1,800–1,900. In other words, about a tenth of that higher level.
That doesn’t mean only 1,800 businesses are being started. More are being started. But businesses also disappear, and here I’m talking about the difference between those two movements in our figures.
For us, that’s a relevant signal. We make accounting software for small businesses, so if fewer are being added in net terms, it affects our market.
It reminds me of the difficult years around the financial crisis. After the crisis, there was a period of bad years and then more mixed ones before things really took off again. I’m trying to work out whether we’re in a similar place now.
My son had a different angle on the new businesses
My son Mads came to work with me today before he goes back to school. Afterwards, we talked about what we’d seen.
He said he thought the situation might be even harder. On TikTok, he sees loads of content about getting rich quickly. He thought some young people might set up businesses based on those kinds of promises without a real business ever coming out of it.
I thought that was an interesting observation. If lots of registrations never turn into real activity, the number of new businesses doesn’t necessarily tell the whole story.
We don’t know how many that applies to. It’s his observation and a possible explanation we’re discussing. But it’s worth thinking about what activity actually lies behind a number.
Yet we’re losing fewer paying customers
Then comes the thing that puzzles me. We also track our churn: the proportion of paying customers we lose.
Around the start of the period, it was just over two per cent a month. That may sound high if you know SaaS businesses. But our customers are the smallest businesses, and some of them close down again.
That means we lose some customers even if they’re happy with the product. When there’s no longer a business, there’s no need for paid accounting software either.
So we expect a certain amount of customer loss. It’s part of the market, and not every cancellation tells you there’s something wrong with the product.
But during 2023, our churn fell almost month by month. From around 2.2 per cent at the start of the year to a provisional figure of around one per cent in December.
There’s still uncertainty in the December figure. It needs to be finalised. Perhaps it’ll be more like 1.4 per cent. But even that is a big improvement from 2.2 per cent.
If you don’t work with these kinds of figures, you might think they’re just tiny decimals. But for a subscription business, that difference is enormous. How many customers you can retain over time matters a great deal.
So in a year when one of our market indicators looks really bad, we’re also seeing some of the lowest customer losses we’ve ever had. That’s not the combination I would immediately have expected.
The new bookkeeping requirements gave us some choices
We’ve also introduced a new business model. The background is the new requirements for digital bookkeeping systems.
We needed the program to meet a series of requirements. As it stood, our free version lacked some of the features needed in the new solution. So we had to decide how to handle it.
One option was to close the free version. Some people recommended that. It would be simpler and might also be more profitable.
Another was simply to leave it as it was. But we didn’t want users to be left with a program that didn’t fit the requirements they needed to meet.
We could also upgrade the free version without changing anything else. But if we gave it more of the features people paid for, some paying customers might choose the free solution instead.
We wanted to preserve the option of getting started for free. At the same time, of course, the business needed to add up.
A better free version with a revenue limit
So we chose to give the free version the new features and set a revenue limit of 100,000 kroner.
That’s a limit in our subscription, not a statement that the law sets precisely that limit for all businesses. Below the limit, our users can continue for free with more features. Above it, they need to choose a paid subscription.
We also created a cheaper paid option. At the prices we’re working with at the time, there’s a solution at around 200 kroner a month and a more comprehensive one at around 300 kroner.
If you want to see what we offer now, you can look at Dinero’s current prices and read about Starter+. The figures I’m discussing here describe the change at the end of 2023.
I’d expected a clear split between the two paid options. We also offered a discount on the more comprehensive solution.
But a very large proportion chose the more expensive one. That surprised me. And then came another surprise.
Many chose to pay for a whole year
Just over 17,000 businesses had received this offer. When we looked at those who had made a choice, we were already a good way into the process.
They could choose to pay monthly or annually. There’s a discount for annual payment, but I’d still expected many to pay monthly.
These were people who’d used the program for free for several years. It was easy to imagine they’d done so because there wasn’t much room in their finances.
But a large proportion chose annual payment. That tells me they at least had the option of putting the money down now rather than spreading payment over the year.
Again: That doesn’t quite fit the picture of financial pressure I’m seeing elsewhere at the same time. I’m not saying it proves anything about all businesses. But in our own figures, it’s an interesting observation.
Lower inflation doesn’t mean cornflakes get cheaper
We’re coming out of a period of high inflation, big energy bills and interest rates that have risen sharply from a low starting point. That’s affected many people’s finances.
One thing I think gets misunderstood is what it means when inflation falls.
If inflation goes from ten per cent to two per cent, that doesn’t automatically mean prices are put back down. It means that, in that example, the price level rises more slowly.
Take a simple calculation: Something costs 100 kroner. After a ten per cent increase, it costs 110 kroner. If the price then rises another two per cent, it becomes 112.20 kroner.
So what became expensive hasn’t become cheap again. It’s just become a little more expensive at a slower pace.
That’s an example of the calculation, not the precise current Danish inflation figures. And prices of individual goods can of course fall even while the overall price level rises.
Energy, for example, has moved differently from many other things. But when people hear inflation has fallen, they shouldn’t necessarily expect all the high supermarket prices to disappear.
I still see people spending money
You’d think interest rates and higher prices would make many people hold back much more. And of course some do.
But at the same time, I read about people booking holidays and going to restaurants. I see people going out.
My friends involved in Museo are still seeing activity. Perhaps Danish guests buy fewer expensive bottles, but they come, buy cocktails and dance. International guests contribute too.
The stock market hasn’t given me a picture of total catastrophe at the end of 2023 either. Some shares have done well, others less well. There’s been a lot of variation.
Those are the kinds of signals that make it hard for me to form one overall picture. I see pressure in some places and continued activity in others.
Economic uncertainty: I don’t know where we are in the cycle
That applies to the broader indicators too. My impression isn’t that unemployment has suddenly shown us a severe crisis. Some of what I read about Denmark and the US still seems quite robust.
Elsewhere, there are more worrying stories. European industry and the Swedish property market are examples of areas I see mentioned. But I’m not an expert on them, and I won’t pretend I can explain every mechanism.
Financing and interest rates can affect people differently depending on how their loans are structured. That’s also something I’m trying to factor into the picture.
My honest conclusion so far is that I haven’t got a fucking clue exactly where we stand.
Have we been through the worst, with things now improving? Are we in something resembling the dreary years after the financial crisis? Or is a bigger downturn ahead?
I follow some people I think are very smart, and they disagree. Some expect worse figures for industry and other parts of the economy in the coming quarters. Others think the worst is over.
I’d like to give you a clear conclusion. But I’d rather tell you what I know and see than invent certainty I don’t have.
I also see continued activity on Saxis and Capino
I also look at Saxis and Capino, which Jannie and I have bought back and are continuing to work on.
On Saxis, activity around smaller businesses has been fairly steady over the year. Businesses are being put up for sale, and businesses are being bought.
On Capino, new investors keep arriving. On average, that might be roughly every other day. And we’re seeing around a couple of new listings a day from businesses seeking funding.
Those are my observations of our platforms around the turn of the year. It’s not a survey of the entire capital market. But there’s life in there.
So while some of the figures we track look strange or bad, things are still happening. Investors want to invest. Businesses are seeking capital. People are buying and selling businesses.
Perhaps we need to get used to normal being abnormal
I’m getting a bit of a sense of a new normal. Some of the relationships we normally use to understand the economy aren’t giving such clear answers right now.
When one figure goes up or down, perhaps we can’t simply assume all the others will follow in the way we’re used to.
That doesn’t mean the economy has lost all its connections. It’s more my experience of being in the middle of something where the usual shortcuts to an explanation aren’t enough.
So perhaps I do have a small conclusion after all: Expect the unexpected.
I’ll be careful myself about taking big risks and burning through cash. I like having some breathing room, both if problems arise and if an opportunity turns up.
It could be an investment that becomes interesting or something else you want to be able to act on. That’s my own way of thinking about the situation, not a prediction of what the market will do.
Even the Rolex example says something about expectations
One small example I’ve noticed is the market for Rolex watches. I’ve seen cases where an unworn watch on the resale market can now be bought for around the price at a dealer.
That’s a different situation from examples where someone could previously buy a watch and expect to resell it at a big premium, perhaps around 30 per cent.
Of course, it varies by watch and market. I’m describing what I’ve noticed, not a fixed pricing rule for every model.
But it’s another of those small signals that makes me think about where expectations and money are heading. Something can look completely different from how it did a year ago.
That’s how the world looks to me right now. Strange in all sorts of ways. I’ve shared my own figures and thoughts, and you can consider what you take from them yourself.
Feel free to follow the podcast in whatever app you use, so you get notified next time I’m thinking out loud. Have a fantastic evening.
Listen to the episode
Episode 36 of Thorborg’s Diary · recorded on 3 January and published on 4 January 2024
Watch the episode on video
Listen in your podcast app:
All episodes on Apple Podcasts · All episodes on Spotify · All episodes on Amazon Music · RSS Feed